My rule in the Derby that has served me well is to throw out any horse that backed up in the final 16th of his prep race. They have to move forward or draw away to get 1 1/4 IMO. This year my rule would disqualify the following:
Brooklyn Strong
Keepmeinmind
Mandaloun
Medina Spirit
Midnight Bourbon
Dynamic One
Hidden Stash
Highly Motivated
Soup and Sandwich
That's 9, and I'm pretty confident in that 8 of these are tosses. Just not sure of Mandaloun and that's because I have a Bluegrass Cat (only time I've been burned) feel about him. No excuse but Cox running him back, working great. Pretty good start to weeding out the field. I know Highly Motivated is a controversial toss but I'll stand by it.
Then a couple of horses to me are auto tosses:
Helium (2 7F races and one 1/16? Has any horse every had less foundation for the Derby?)
King Fury (again, nothing longer than 1 1/16. You have to have at least go 1 1/8 in my mind)
Bourbonic (bad Wood, best Beyer 89, one that could come back to bite me since his race was visually impressive flying at the end but such a terrible field/race)
Sainthood (slow, faced nothing, 84 Beyer)
Like the King (slow, faced nothing, 86 Beyer)
So that's another 5, or 14 to throw out if you count Mandaloun. Good place to start. That leaves 6 as contenders and most likely to hit the super IMHO
Known Agenda 6-1
O Besos 20-1
Hot Rod Charlie 8-1
Essential Quality 2-1
Rock Your World 5-1
Super Stock 30-1
I'm going to focus on these 6 and make a decision on what to do with Mandaloun (15-1). He's sort of like Super Stock to me. Don't like either to win but could finish and get a piece. As you know I don't love Essential Quality to win this, but it looks like he recovered after the iffy work/jogs according to Welsch so he has to be considered for a piece.
Still trying to figure out who I'm willing to key with Known Agenda drawing the 1 hole. Seems like there's money to be made