If I were a GM and I had to chose between Manning and Flacco now, sure I'd take Flacco because of his age, but Manning throughout most of his career was sensational. Most top QBs are efficient, not sensational. In my opinion, only Dan Marino and Manning were super-players at the position, because they could complete passes with pinpoint precision to receivers that were well covered and no other QBs in history could do that with the consistency they had. And they both won a high percentage of games even though they rarely had a good defense to support them.
|