Well, it was a little of both. He actually was making the case that vs the 4, the 3 was a much better bet.

Since no other handicapping was discussed, it wasn't exactly a pick, BUT , I'll give credit for pointing out the overlay.

There are lots of these every day.

Great call sir

your '3 vs 4' turned out great! :ThmbUp:

race looked 'random' to me. I felt someone would win by 'default'. I feel like if I play races like that, and I don't have a love or hate for specific horses, the favorite wins often enough that the costly coverage adds up.

But, that was good enough of a legitimate point by you in the original post, and a big payout result that I have to question myself.